I am not an atheist in the way are Harris, Dawkins, Hitchens, and Dennett, but I am also not a theist in any way, so I have been enjoying watching this new wrinkle in Western culture develop and play itself out. Very interesting.
One good quote:
Bertrand Russell, who had a prodigious knowledge of history and a crisp wit, claimed in 1930 that he could think of only two useful contributions that religion had made to civilization. It had helped fix the calendar, and it had made Egyptian priests observe eclipses carefully enough to predict them. He could at least have added Bach’s St. Matthew Passion and more than a few paintings; but perhaps the legacy of religion is too large a conundrum to be argued either way. The history of the West has been so closely interwoven with the history of religious institutions and ideas that it is hard to be confident about what life would have been like without them. One of Kingsley Amis’s lesser-known novels, “The Alteration,” tried to envisage an alternative course for modern history in which the Reformation never happened, science is a dirty word, and in 1976 most of the planet is ruled by a Machiavellian Pope from Yorkshire. In this world, Jean-Paul Sartre is a Jesuit and the central mosaic in Britain’s main cathedral is by David Hockney. That piece of fancy is dizzying enough on its own. But imagine attempting such a thought experiment in the contrary fashion, and rolling it back several thousand years to reveal a world with no churches, mosques, or temples. The idea that people would have been nicer to one another if they had never got religion, as Hitchens, Dawkins, and Harris seem to think, is a strange position for an atheist to take. For if man is wicked enough to have invented religion for himself he is surely wicked enough to have found alternative ways of making mischief.
Read the whole thing.
Tags:
1 comment:
I am with you -- a non-theist, not an atheist.
But I do think religion does a lot of questionable good -- keeping lots of people from doing terrible mischief solely because they have a hope of being rewarded in an afterlife.
So, for all the bad, I think there is more-than-offsetting good.
Also, as one buddhist blog quoting Henny Youngman remarked, religion is what gives us most of our holidays.
Post a Comment